Profenno’s Pizzeria

Reviews

• Katy B.

  star star star star star_border 7 June 2026

  Wings! Wings! Wings! Do I have your attention? This place hosts the best 40 cent wing night on Wednesday's that I've found Southern Maine. The wings are really tasty any night, but Wednesday night they are a steal and offer a ton of different flavors. So far the jalapeño mango, garlic Parmesan,  and sweet Thai chili have been my favorites. They also have taco, buffalo, habanero blueberry or mango sometimes, Cajun, barbecue, naked, to name a few. It's always changing. The wings are crispy on the outside and just perfect. You can wash them down with one of the daily draft specials and walk out with a $10 tab. Other nights are just as good. Profenno's has dinner specials nightly and a solid everyday menu with pizza, sandwiches, pub meals and more. If you don't feel like dining in, you can always go to the store side and get your food to go. This is a decent neighborhood bar on the slightly divier side, but don't let appearances fool you! There is plenty of parking, locals to chat up at the bar and friendly bartenders waiting to take your order.

• Courtney C.

  star star star star_border star_border 3 June 2026

  Local pub fare restaurant and bar scene in Westbrook. Hometown sports feel inside with booths along the walls and small high top tables in the middle. Long bar in the front with TVs and liquor/draft beer selections.
  
  Weekends and nights it gets very packed, shoulder to shoulder. Mostly 50+ folks. Karaoke on the weekends. There is an upstairs with pool and darts but unless you're on the of the regulars who plays up there, you are not going to be able to play. The few times I've ventured up the stairs I received death stares and felt very unwelcome so I just walked back downstairs.
  
  The liquor drinks are okay, cheaper than downtown Portland as they should be. I don't ask for anything fancy as its usually very busy and it's not the fancy type of bar.
  
  The food is typical pub fair. They have the 50 cent wing specials during happy hour but only the bone-in kind so I don't order them. I usually order the broccoli chicken pizza but they cover the thing in mushrooms and I have to pick them off, when they remember the "no mushrooms" I'm happy with the pizza it's really good.
  
  My friends and I will sometimes stop in here as the last stop of the night on our way home from downtown Portland, or after visiting Mast Landing which is the brewery behind Profenno's.

• John F.

  star star star star_border star_border 31 May 2026

  Only three stars today.  We had to go find the waitress who was in the kitchen conversing. Out of four orders two were correct.  I ordered a large sandwich and and got small (charged for a large).  My friend got a sandwich that supposed to come with fries but came with chips.  Another friend got a plain spaghetti/sauce dinner that comes with no bread or roll.  The fourth and final order was correct and ok.  
  We go here all the time, and it seems to be slipping as if no one cares whether they have customers or not.
  The food is good though.

• Staci H.

  star star star star_border star_border 30 May 2026

  The skinny is this...every part of me wants to love this place it's within 5 minutes of home, they serve sandwiches, pizza, calzones and salads.  We have ordered twice.  First time a five cheese calzone with Alfredo sauce instead of red sauce (avoiding that for the baby), they gave me a 20 minute wait time.  My husband waited 30 and still no ordered.  He asked about it only to learn they had lost the order.  They put it in ASAP, apologized, gave us the food free and a gift card to return.  Awesome I thought that is honestly making sure the costumer was happy.  The calzone tasted great, full of cheese! Great bag for the buck.
  This past weekend we order same calzone but with pineapple and red sauce (praying the baby can handle it) and a side garden salad. The calzone was good but ice cold after warming it up the crust was super tough. The salad was pathetic. Mostly lettuce green peppers and onion. It has one cucumber slice and like three tomatoes.  I would not order that again.  
  I will try a third time because like I said I WANT to love this place and I pray it's been a fluke thing each time!

• Victoria P.

  star star star star star 29 May 2026

  The weekly specials here are ridiculous! Seriously - who gives away free pizza?! FREE PIZZA!
  
  OH! And during Trivia night on Thursdays, they sometimes have leftover wings along with free pizza....FREE WINGS ANNNND FREE PIZZA.
  
  Dude.
  
  It's not a fancy spot, but you can get some decent bar food here. Very relaxed atmosphere to grub and drink. There is a brewery right next door as well so heeeey :)
  
  Worth checking out :)